Skip to content
  • Free UK delivery on every order until 31 December

Welcome guest

Please login or register

Make it a Christmas double

Murder Mystery Games to Play at Home

Murder Mystery Games to Play at Home

The best murder mystery games give you a case to solve, real evidence to examine and a reveal worth waiting for. A boxed game is the easiest way to play at home: open the box, read the file and start investigating. Nutty Orange escape room games are made for one to four players aged 14 and over.

What is a murder mystery game?

A murder mystery game is a game where players work out who committed a crime, and how, by studying clues and questioning the evidence. The term covers a lot of ground. Some are party games with costumes and assigned characters. Others are puzzle-led case files you solve at the table. "Murder mystery" is also the phrase people search for when they simply want a gripping detective game, so you will see it used for games that have no murder in them at all.

What types of murder mystery games are there?

Most fall into four groups, and the right one depends on who is playing and how much prep you want.

  • Party kits: each guest plays a character, usually with costumes and a host. Fun, but you need a bigger group and some organising.
  • Boxed case files: sealed evidence, documents and puzzles for a small group around a table. No host and no costumes.
  • Subscription boxes: one story delivered in parts over several weeks.
  • Digital games: played on a screen or app, without the feel of holding evidence.

For a small group that wants a complete evening with no preparation, a boxed case file is usually the simplest choice. If you are comparing boxed games, what to look for in a solve-a-crime subscription box and our guide to games like Hunt A Killer help you weigh a one-off box against a monthly one.

What makes a good murder mystery game?

Three things separate the memorable ones from the forgettable. First, a story that matters: every puzzle should exist for a reason, not just to fill space. Second, physical evidence you can pass around the table, because holding a photograph or a sealed envelope changes how you play. Third, a fair difficulty curve, with easy early wins, a few lateral-thinking puzzles and a finale that only works once you have absorbed every clue.

Look for a hint system too, so a single tough cipher does not end the evening, and check that nothing needs an app. Our guide to what should be inside an escape room game box lists what to expect.

Which Nutty Orange murder mystery games can you play at home?

Every Nutty Orange game is a self-contained case with physical evidence, made for one to four players aged 14 and over and playing in roughly 90 minutes.

Without Trace: a missing person mystery

Without Trace is a detective mystery. Sophie Scott has gone missing and the evidence does not quite add up. You examine evidence sheets, compare timelines, decode notes and read maps to work out who is telling the truth. It eases in gently, so it suits a first case.

Sentinel: a spy mystery

Sentinel is a spy mystery game. You step into the role of a secret agent with codes, gadgets and puzzles that push harder. It is the pick for a group that has solved a few cases and wants a tougher one.

ChristMystery: a festive mystery

ChristMystery unravels a haunting Victorian tale, with clues hidden in strange artefacts. It is a cosy, slightly spooky choice for a winter evening.

How do you set up a murder mystery night at home?

Clear one table and keep the evidence in the order the game asks for. Read the story introduction aloud, put phones away, and agree a hint rule before you begin. Say your theories out loud: explaining a guess is half of solving it. For a first-timer's walkthrough, see how to play an escape room game at home, and for a themed night with more guests, how to host a murder mystery party.

Are there murder mystery games for families?

Yes, though the gentler picks suit younger players better than a grown-up case file. Our guide to murder mystery games for families covers what to look for, and whodunit games for families goes into reading level and tone.

Frequently asked questions

What are the best murder mystery games to play at home?

The best ones give you a case file, real physical evidence and a reveal you can reach in one evening. Look for a strong story, puzzles that build in difficulty, a hint system and no app or screen. Nutty Orange escape room games such as Without Trace and Sentinel are built this way.

How many people can play a murder mystery game?

It varies by game. Nutty Orange mystery boxes are made for one to four players, so they suit a couple, a small group of friends or a family table. Party-style games with assigned roles usually need more people.

How long does a murder mystery game take?

Most boxed games take roughly one to two hours from opening the first envelope to the final answer. Nutty Orange games run for around 90 minutes.

Do murder mystery games need an app?

The best boxed games do not. Everything you need is inside the box: sealed evidence, paper clues and physical puzzles, so phones can stay out of the evening.

What age are murder mystery games suitable for?

It depends on the game. Nutty Orange mystery games are made for ages 14 and over. Our guides to family and kids' mystery games cover gentler options for younger players.

Is a murder mystery game the same as an escape room game?

They overlap. A murder mystery is about working out who did it and how. An escape room game is about solving linked puzzles to reach a goal. Many boxed games combine both, setting the investigation inside a series of puzzles.

Can you replay a murder mystery game?

Usually not with the same group, because the answer is known once solved. Many people pass the box on to friends or family to open cold.

Ready to play?

If you want a murder mystery game that feels like a proper investigation, pick a case, clear the table and see how long it takes to crack it. Browse the full range at nuttyorange.com.

Browse all Nutty Orange mystery games at nuttyorange.com.

The Best Mystery Games to Give as Christmas Gifts
christmas-board-game

Your Cart

Your Cart is empty
Let's fix that

Your Wishlist

Item is added to cart